
Hamilton County Public Defender Office Visits Caracole
On Friday, June 14, 2024, the Hamilton County Public Defender office had the distinct opportunity to visit Caracole, a renowned HIV advocacy organization based in Cincinnati’s Northside. This visit provided an in-depth look into Caracole’s vital work and the challenges faced by individuals affected by HIV/AIDS within the criminal justice system.
Caracole has been at the forefront of providing comprehensive services and support to individuals living with HIV/AIDS, significantly impacting the community. The organization offers a range of programs aimed at promoting health equity and cultural competency, addressing the unique needs of their clients.
During the visit, the Hamilton County Public Defender office learned about the various strategies Caracole employs to support those affected by HIV/AIDS. These strategies include advocating for the decriminalization of HIV, which is a crucial step towards reducing stigma and ensuring fair treatment for all individuals regardless of their health status.
Caracole’s efforts to promote health equity involve comprehensive education and outreach programs designed to enhance understanding and foster inclusive environments. Their commitment to cultural competency ensures that their services are accessible and sensitive to the diverse backgrounds of their clients.
This engagement highlighted the significant challenges faced by individuals living with HIV/AIDS, particularly within the criminal justice system. Stigma and discrimination often exacerbate these challenges, making the work of organizations like Caracole even more essential. By advocating for decriminalization and providing unwavering support, Caracole aims to create a fairer, more equitable society for all.
The visit to Caracole was an enlightening experience for the Hamilton County Public Defender office, emphasizing the importance of collaboration and understanding in addressing the complex issues surrounding HIV/AIDS. Caracole’s dedication and advocacy continue to inspire and drive positive change within the community.

Celebrating Christie Lee Griffin’s Dedication to Community Service
We are incredibly proud of Christie Lee Griffin for her unwavering dedication to serving our community, both through her work with the Public Defender Office and now as a board member with Caracole. Christie’s commitment to justice, advocacy, and community engagement shines brightly in every role she undertakes.
Caracole provides essential services in prevention, medical care, pharmacological support, and housing assistance, all of which are crucial for supporting at-risk and infected individuals in our community. As a board member, Christie will contribute her expertise and passion to help Caracole continue its vital mission.
Christie’s involvement with Caracole exemplifies the core values of our office. Her dedication reflects our collective commitment to making a positive difference in the lives of those we serve. We are confident that Christie will bring valuable insights and a strong sense of justice to Caracole’s board, further enhancing their impact on the community.
We look forward to seeing the positive changes and continued support Christie will help bring about in her new role. Her work stands as a testament to the importance of community service and the profound impact that dedicated individuals can have on those in need.

Mallory Reed Secures First Jury Trial Win for Theft Charge State Dismisses Assault and Menacing Charges
Congratulations to Mallory Reed on securing her first jury trial win for a theft charge on May 2nd. Additionally, the State chose to dismiss the two charges of assault and menacing, Mallory’s successful defense strategy centered around highlighting the lack of crucial evidence and inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case.
Mallory expressed gratitude to her colleagues, particularly Karinne Hill, for their support during the trial process. She also acknowledged the contributions of Darceny Winston and Ben Ranz in developing effective trial strategies and analogies that resonated with the jury.
Overall, Mallory’s successful defense underscores the importance of thorough preparation, effective advocacy, and strategic trial presentation in securing favorable outcomes for clients facing serious charges.


Clay Achieves First Jury Trial Victory in OVI Case, Secures Not-Guilty Verdict for Client
Clay secured his first jury trial win in a marijuana OVI case with Mike Welsh assisting him. Their client, N.P., had crashed his truck during a seizure, and a subsequent blood test showed active marijuana despite his medical marijuana card. Initially hesitant due to his injuries, N.P. proceeded with the trial after Mike’s reassurance and a judge’s flexible schedule.
The prosecution’s witnesses could not conclusively link the client’s condition to marijuana impairment, and their expert acknowledged that frequent marijuana users might not be impaired even with active marijuana in their system.
A significant legal debate centered on whether the medical marijuana defense was an affirmative defense. Clay successfully argued it wasn’t, leading to favorable jury instructions. The jury returned a not-guilty verdict, citing insufficient evidence of impairment and the expert’s testimony.

Urban Expungement Information Session THURSDAY MAY 23 6 P.M. to 7:30 P.M.
Join our Information Session at the Holloman Center for Social Justice to learn how you or someone you know may be able to start the record expungement process!

Gabe Cripe Secures Victory in First-Ever Jury Trial, Showcasing Dedication to Justice

We are delighted to share exciting news regarding our team member, Gabe Cripe, who has won his first-ever jury trial. This achievement is a testament to Gabe’s dedication, skill, and unwavering commitment to justice.
Gabe’s successful representation in this case was one of the most challenging legal battles our team has faced. His meticulous preparation, strategic approach, and tireless advocacy played a pivotal role in achieving a favorable outcome for our client.
We extend our heartfelt congratulations to Gabe for this remarkable achievement. Additionally, we express gratitude to Scott Nazzarine, Gabe’s team leader and second chair, whose guidance and support were instrumental throughout the trial.
Gabe’s triumph highlights our team’s collective excellence and unwavering commitment to upholding justice and advocating for our client’s rights. As we celebrate this milestone, we reaffirm our dedication to serving our community with integrity, diligence, and compassion. Congratulations, Gabe, on this well-deserved victory, and may it be the first of many more to come.

Triumph in the Courtroom: Defense Attorney Darceny Winston Secures Not Guilty Verdict in Landmark OVI Case
Defense attorney Darceny Winston achieved a remarkable victory for her client in an OVI trial. The case originated in Green Township and presented a compelling narrative. Winston’s client was found asleep in the front seat of her car at an intersection.

Crucially, upon exiting the vehicle, the client displayed no signs of impairment. Throughout the trial, Winston and co-counsel Sharonda Hunter meticulously challenged the prosecution’s narrative, highlighted inconsistencies in the officer’s testimony, and asserted that the client’s condition was due to exhaustion.
After only a few hours of deliberation, the jury delivered a Not Guilty verdict. Winston & Hunter’s triumph stands as a beacon of hope for those facing similar challenges and underscores the critical role of skilled defense attorneys in safeguarding the rights and liberties of individuals.

Acquittal Against Odds: Dallas Guttman and Sarah Vanderhoff Secure Not Guilty Verdict in DUI Trial, Protecting Mother’s Freedom

Dallas Guttman and Sarah Vanderhoff won a jury trial for a client who was accused of drinking and driving.
She faced a minimum of 20 days in jail and maximum of 180 days. The client is a mother of school-age children and could not afford to go to jail for 20 days for something she did not do.
The case turned on whether the client was drunk. The police claimed client failed the field sobriety test.
Dallas and Sarah successfully argued that the officer performed the tests incorrectly and that the client acted normally under the circumstances. The jury agreed and came back with a not guilty verdict within an hour.

Angela Chang & Stan Ross Address Youth Justice on ‘Cincinnati Edition’
In a compelling segment on Cincinnati Edition, HCPD’s Angela Chang teamed up with Stan Ross, Executive Director of the Positive Influence Team, to shed light on a pressing issue: kids involved in car thefts and their journey through the juvenile justice system.
With a focus on understanding the dynamics behind juvenile offending, Angela and Stan delved into what happens when these young individuals enter the juvenile court system, exploring the factors driving their behavior and the challenges they face.
Highlighting the innovative approach of Stan’s Credible Messenger program, the discussion offered hope and solutions for addressing youth offending and reducing recidivism rates.
Listeners can catch the full segment here and learn more about the Positive Influence Team by visiting the link right here. Join us in supporting initiatives that make a positive impact on our youth and communities.

Expungement Information Sessions: Navigating Towards A Better Future
Residents of Hamilton County February 29th and March 1st participated in Expungement Information sessions hosted by the Urban League of Greater Southwestern Ohio in collaboration with the Public Defender’s Office.
The sessions, aimed at providing vital information about expungement and sealing records, with the support of the Justice Bus and Civic Engagement Unit, individuals received valuable resources and assistance, ensuring they were equipped with the knowledge needed to navigate.
In addition to gaining insights into expungement procedures, attendees were treated to snacks and refreshments, creating a welcoming and supportive atmosphere for learning and empowerment.
These sessions underscored the commitment of the community to promoting justice and providing opportunities for individuals to move forward positively in their lives. By empowering residents with the information and resources they need to clear their records, the Urban League and the Public Defender’s Office are fostering a culture of second chances and redemption.
Expungement Information Sessions Recap
